Thank you for joining me again as I make my way through Mr. Lischetti's fantastic decorating book. As I mentioned in my first review, I was quite surprised to find recipes and baking instruction in what I thought was simply a sculpting book. I love a good sponge cake, and Mr. Lischetti's approach to cake assembly using a ring mould appealed to both myself and the baking staff here at Pink Cake Box. So we collectively decided to take a stab at it. I’m not a pastry chef (but have worked in bakeries and kitchens) so I value the opinion of our talented staff as far as methods go. I will include their opinions as well as my own. We decided to test out the moulded cake construction method.

"It is a very versatile book with a great many possibilities...Excellent all around!"

My associate and talented pastry chef Kimberly did the baking while I asked questions and took pictures. The sponge cake recipe wasn't excessively fussy, though I can see a home cook having to remake it once or twice possibly to get it down pat. Kimberly commented that the recipe can only be doubled which would make it awkward when baking enough layers for a large tiered cake. Incidently, while we don't have our own sponge cake recipe to share, we've posted several different recipes in our recipe section.

Sponge Cake Recipe Making

The sponge came out of the oven in just about six minutes, we turned it out and wrapped it in plastic until cool. As advertised, it stayed moist and flexible.

Kimberly suggested soaking the cake with syrup before cutting for the mould, which worked out quite well. Construction was easy and we had a filled cake ready to chill in a fairly short amount of time.

Constructing Assembling Sponge Cake

We forewent Mr. Lischetti’s icing technique (though if I was at home I might well follow it) in favor of the classic Pink Cake Box version as seen in our Cakes 101 DVD.

Icing the Cake

Buttercream Iced Cake

We chilled it again for a final coat and set about decorating it. Kimberly’s professional opinion was that the mould technique made it much easier to get a crisp, straight edge. We used a meringue based butter cream as advised in the book.

Decorating! This was hard because I had both the fairy from the book and bunny from the Cake Masters class. The consensus in the shop was that the fairy should go on the cake. I fondanted in ivory and covered my board in green.  

Final Cake for Book review

The general idea was to make the top of the cake into a flower in which our pink fairy could reside. I inserted orchid sepals to make a fantasy flower.

Flowers atop buttercream cake

I cut "grass" for the base.

Final Cake for Book Review

I textured a piece of fondant a little smaller than the center of my cake using a clean, dry dishtowel.

Final Cake with Flower

And the final result...!

Woodland Fairy Figure on Sponge Cake

What else can I say? The baking and construction turned out exactly as expected and I do think this was the easiest cake I've fondanted yet due to the extremely smooth sides created by the sponge cake in the mould.

I think there is a lot to take away from Animation in Sugar whether you aspire to Mr. Lischetti's aesthetic of modern whimsey or not. It is a very versatile book with a great many possibilities. Excellent all around, and I expect I will be recommending it to students and co-workers alike for years to come.

Animation in Sugar Book review

Book: Animation in Sugar by Carlos Lischetti

Skill Level: Advanced/ Beginner/ Intermediate

Rating: ★★★★★

Want more reviews?

Sign up for our newsletter for more reviews, tips and promotions!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Cake Toppers Techniques

Check out our online Cake Toppers Techniques: Figure Modeling Class!


Learn More »
Cake Decorating Classes

Looking to stay on top of the latest ways to learn about cake decorating? Overwhelmed with all the options out there and don't know where to start? Then our Cake Decorator Starter Guide has you covered!

Disclosure: We receive a small commission on sales of this Book. So thank-you for supporting us. We only recommend products or services we use personally for teaching our own cake decorators at the bakery.

Share the love!

Subscribe for Updates!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Anna Puchalski

Anna Puchalski

Anna is a classically trained sculptor and illustrator who started her career in cake decorating with Ron Ben Israel in 2000. Since then she has worked for a number of well known cake studios in the New York area doing complex sugar work and design. Her specialties include freehand painting,...

Read More »

6 thoughts on “Animation in Sugar Book Review Part 2

  1. I would love to buy each of these books, but on Amazon they say ” out of Print”… were can I order.. They look wondeful..Thanks..

    • Good News Kathy – here is what the publisher said:

      Hi Anna,

      Thank you for your email and kind reviews of the book. The book has been extremely popular and the high demand keeps depleting our stocks. The good news is that the book is still in print and we are expecting new stock to arrive on 17th January. Your readers should therefore be able to purchase the book again later in the month.

      • I am very excited to stumble upon this book. I just won an award for the children’s book industry and the medium I used was cake and fondant. Everyone was so thrilled with the idea of cake in an illustration. I can’t wait to get my hands on this beautiful book.

        • Thanks for visiting! You will definitely enjoy this book (once it’s back in stock).

          I think your cake illustrations concept is a wonderfully creative idea! I took a look at the Cakelustrations section on your site and it looks really interesting! Is it available for sale online?

          • Thank you Anne,

            I’m really looking forward to making more Caklustrations. This was my first and I really need to make more for my portfolio. I’m sure I can only improve. I do not have a book yet, the Cakelustration I did was my first in cake. I am looking forward to what this year has in store. I’ll let you know when I have my first cakelustration children’s book published.

            Your fairy is beautiful.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for our Newsletter

Enter your email:

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.